“You Cost Too Much”
The short answer: Don’t defend the number and don’t discount. Pause and ask, “Tell me more about that.” Find out whether it’s a real budget limit or doubt about the value. Then help them see what staying where they are is costing them, show a specific result for someone like them, and let go of buyers who only care about price.
Your prospect just said your price is too high. Your stomach dropped. You started thinking about a discount before they even asked for one.
Stop. When a prospect says “you’re too expensive,” they are rarely telling you the whole story. They are giving you the easy version of a harder thing. Your job is to find the harder thing. Here is how, in five steps.
Step 1: Pause. Don’t react.
Most owners either defend the number right away or start figuring out how low they can go. Both tell the prospect the objection landed.
Instead, let two seconds of silence sit. Then say: “Tell me more about that.”
What comes next is the real objection. A bad past experience. Doubt about results. A spouse or partner they need to convince. A competitor’s name dropped to see what you’ll do. Work with that, not the price.
Step 2: Diagnose before you prescribe
A price objection is either a budget limit or a value question. They need different answers.
- Budget limit: “We only have this much set aside right now.” That is a facts problem. Adjust payment terms, timing, or scope.
- Value question: “I want to make sure we get our money’s worth.” That is a clarity problem. A lower price won’t fix it. It only confirms their doubt.
Ask directly: “Is this a budget issue, or are you not yet sure the investment makes sense?” Most people respect the directness.
Step 3: Shift from cost to consequence
Research by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky found that people feel losses roughly twice as strongly as equal gains. Your prospect isn’t weighing your price against what they’ll gain. They’re weighing it against the fear of getting it wrong.
So make the cost of doing nothing visible. Ask: “What happens if you stay where you are for another six months?” Let them answer in their own words. Now you are no longer defending a price. You are helping them see what the status quo costs.
“The simple believes everything, but the prudent gives thought to his steps.” (Proverbs 14:15, ESV)
Help your prospect think through every step, not just the invoice.
Step 4: Anchor to outcomes, not features
A prospect comparing you to a cheaper competitor is comparing inputs. Point them to outputs. Skip the credentials and the process. Tell them what changed for a client like them: “A client in a similar spot came to us with this problem. Six months later, here is what was different.”
Specific results persuade. General promises do not.
Step 5: Let the wrong buyer go
Some buyers care about price above everything and always will. They are not your clients. Win them with a discount and you have bought a problem: they will push on price at renewal and won’t refer people who value your work.
In Matthew 7:6, Jesus warns against giving what is valuable to those who won’t value it. You are not called to win every deal. You are called to steward your time and capacity for the clients you are built to serve.
A price objection in the first minute usually means the fit was never there. One that comes after a thorough conversation can usually be solved with clarity. Work the second. Release the first.
The five steps at a glance
- Pause and let them talk.
- Find out if it’s budget or value.
- Turn the fear toward the cost of staying stuck.
- Show a specific outcome.
- Let price-only buyers go.
The goal is not to close every deal. It is to close the right ones, at the right price, with people who will be glad they said yes.
If you want to sell with confidence without compromising who you are, let’s talk. See how we help owners build a business that grows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I offer a discount when a customer says my price is too high?
Usually not. Find out first whether it’s a budget limit or a value question. Discounting a value question confirms the doubt.
How do I raise prices without losing customers?
Tie the price to specific outcomes, raise it with new clients first, and expect to lose a few price-only buyers.
How do I know if a prospect is the wrong fit?
If price is their first and main concern before they understand the outcome, they are likely to be a price-only buyer.
What exactly should I say when someone says my price is too high?
Three lines work in order: “Tell me more about that.” Then, “Is this a budget issue, or are you not yet sure it’s worth it?” Then, “What happens if you stay where you are for another six months?”
Should I list my prices on my website?
Showing a starting price, such as “$2,500 and up,” filters out price-only buyers before the first call and saves both of you time.
How do I help someone with a real budget limit without cutting my price?
Change the terms, not the rate: spread the payments, phase the work, or reduce the scope to fit what they can invest now.
How should I tell current clients about a price increase?
Give 30 to 60 days’ notice, apply it at their next renewal, and explain it in terms of the results you deliver. New clients pay the new price right away.
Ready for your next step?
Start with a complimentary conversation with Karl. You will leave with a clear next step.
Talk With Karl