Key takeaways

  • Manager engagement fell from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025, according to Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace report, while individual contributor engagement held near 20%.
  • Gallup’s research shows managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement. When managers burn out, their teams follow.
  • Managers who receive ongoing, coaching-focused development show up to 22% higher engagement, and their teams show up to 18% higher engagement (Gallup).
  • Manager burnout is reversed by the owner: hand over real decisions, coach managers weekly, and make every manager responsible for developing someone else.

Every week I sit across the table from an owner who says some version of the same sentence about one of his managers. “He’s a good guy. He just isn’t stepping up.”

After more than 10,000 coaching sessions, I have learned to hear that sentence differently. It is rarely a report on the manager. It is almost always a report on how the manager is being led.

Gallup’s data now says the same thing on a global scale. In its State of the Global Workplace report, manager engagement fell from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025. Over the same stretch, individual contributors barely moved, from 20% to 19%. Global employee engagement now sits at 20%, and Gallup traces much of that decline to what is happening in the manager’s chair.

For decades, managers carried what Gallup calls an engagement premium. They were more invested in the work than the people they led. That premium has nearly disappeared. Your managers are now almost as checked out as the teams they are called to lead.

It is easy to read numbers like these as a workforce trend, something happening out there to other companies. They are not. They are a leadership trend, and it begins much closer to your desk than you think.

What Manager Engagement Is and Why It Decides Your Culture

Manager engagement is the degree to which your managers are invested in the work, clear on what is expected of them, and committed to developing the people under them. It is not mood. It is ownership.

That distinction matters because of where the weight falls. Gallup’s research shows managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement. Your frontline people do not experience your vision statement. They experience their manager on a Tuesday afternoon. When the manager withers, the team withers with him.

So the real question is not whether your people are engaged. The real question is why the people leading them are wearing out first.

Why Manager Engagement Is Falling

Gallup’s research found that manager engagement drops as teams grow larger when managers spend much of their time doing individual contributor work, and that strong manager talent offsets the effect. In small and mid-sized companies, I see three patterns sitting underneath the numbers.

We promote the best doer and call him a leader. The top technician becomes the foreman. The top salesperson becomes the sales manager. He was rewarded for doing, so he keeps doing, and now he does it with five more people waiting on him.

The owner never let go of the decisions. The manager carries responsibility without authority. Every hard call still flows up to you. He owns the outcome but not the steering wheel.

Nobody is developing the manager. He received a title, a raise, and a heavier load. He never received a coach.

None of this is new. One of the oldest leadership stories in Scripture describes it almost word for word.

Moses, Jethro, and the Leader Who Will Not Let Go

Exodus 18 opens with Moses sitting from morning until evening, hearing every case the people bring to him. His father-in-law Jethro watches one full day of it and gives his verdict:

“What you are doing is not good. You and the people with you will certainly wear yourselves out, for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to do it alone.” (Exodus 18:17-18, ESV)

The Hebrew behind “certainly wear yourselves out” is nabol tibbol. The verb nabel is doubled for emphasis. It means to wither, to droop, to fall like a leaf from a branch. It is the same verb Psalm 1:3 uses for the righteous man whose “leaf does not wither.” Jethro is telling Moses that he is a tree dropping its leaves in the middle of summer.

Notice the phrase “and the people with you.” Exhaustion at the top never stays at the top. What Gallup measured across more than 140 countries, Jethro saw in a single afternoon.

Gregory the Great, who led the church in Rome at the end of the sixth century, saw it too. In his Book of Pastoral Rule, he wrote that Moses “is judged by the reproof of Jethro, who was of alien race, because with ill-advised labour he devotes himself to the people’s earthly affairs: and counsel too is presently given him, that he should appoint others in his stead for settling earthly strifes, and he himself should be more free to learn spiritual secrets for the instruction of the people” (Part II, Chapter 7).

Ill-advised labour. Gregory did not call Moses lazy or proud. He called him busy in the wrong place. The man who spoke with God face to face was spending his days on work others could carry, and the people paid for it.

Jethro’s answer was not a time management trick. He told Moses to find able, trustworthy men who feared God and place them over thousands, hundreds, fifties, and tens. Then he drew the line:

“Every great matter they shall bring to you, but any small matter they shall decide themselves. So it will be easier for you, and they will bear the burden with you. If you do this, God will direct you, you will be able to endure, and all this people also will go to their place in peace.” (Exodus 18:22-23, ESV)

Moses did not lower his standard. He multiplied his leadership.

Jethro solved the load problem. Paul goes one step further and shows what leaders are actually for:

“And what you have heard from me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men, who will be able to teach others also.” (2 Timothy 2:2, ESV)

The Greek word for “entrust” is paratithēmi. It means to set something beside another person as a trust, to make a deposit. It belongs to the same family as parathēkē, the “good deposit” Paul tells Timothy to guard in 2 Timothy 1:14. The word for “able” is hikanos: competent, sufficient, fit for the task. Count the generations in one verse: Paul, Timothy, faithful men, others. Four layers of leaders, each one carrying a deposit and passing it on.

A manager is not a place to park work. A manager is a man you deposit leadership into, so he can deposit it into others.

Moses had a father-in-law willing to tell him the truth. Here it is for you.

You Built a Room Full of Waiting

If your managers only execute your decisions, you did not build leaders. You built a room full of people waiting for you.

Waiting wears men out. A manager who carries the weight of the result without the authority to shape it will wither. He stops bringing ideas, because ideas die on your desk. He stops developing his people, because no one ever developed him. Then you look at the team, see the drift, and conclude you need better people.

You do not need better people. You need to do what Jethro told Moses to do.

A coaching culture does not start with a training program for frontline staff. It starts with the owner coaching the managers. You cannot build in your company what you refuse to practice yourself.

The encouraging part is that this is one of the most reversible problems in any business. The research is clear about what changes it.

What Coaching Does for Manager Engagement

Gallup compared managers who completed coaching-focused development with peers who did not. The developed managers showed:

In Gallup’s best-practice organizations, 79% of managers are engaged, nearly four times the global average. Gallup’s own counsel is to prioritize ongoing development over one-time training, because training delivers information without changing behavior.

The gap between 22% and 79% is not talent. It is whether someone is investing in the manager week after week. In your company, that someone is you.

How Owners Turn Manager Burnout Around

1. Give back the small matters. Write down every decision that came to you in the last two weeks. Circle the ones your manager could have made. Hand those decisions over in writing, with real authority. Then do not take them back the first time he makes a call you would have made differently. That is Exodus 18:22 in practice.

2. Replace the status meeting with a coaching conversation. Give each manager thirty minutes a week. Ask before you tell:

Then hold him to his own answer. Coaching skills for managers are learned by watching an owner use them.

3. Make the deposit visible. Ask every manager two questions: Who are you developing? What are you handing them next? If the answer is no one, you have found where leadership in your company stops.

Before you hand any of this to your managers, answer three questions yourself:

The Signal, Not the Problem

Your managers are not the problem. They are the signal. Their engagement tells you whether leadership in your company is being multiplied or hoarded.

Moses listened to Jethro and did everything he said. Moses endured, the people went home in peace, and Israel gained leaders who could carry the load beside him. The same is available to you, and it starts with the next decision you give away.

Start by seeing where you stand as a leader of leaders. Take the free LEAD self-assessment at higherimpact.me/leadership-self-assessment.

If you are ready to build managers who carry the weight with you, book a conversation with me at cal.higherimpact.me/time-with-karl.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is manager engagement declining?

Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace report found global manager engagement fell from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025, a nine-point drop, while individual contributor engagement fell just one point. In small and mid-sized businesses, the common drivers are larger teams, responsibility without decision-making authority, and little or no ongoing development for the manager.

How does manager engagement affect employees?

Gallup’s research shows managers account for 70% of the variance in team engagement. Employees experience the company through their direct manager, so when a manager burns out, team engagement, retention, and performance decline with him.

What coaching skills do managers need?

Managers need to ask before they tell, listen for what is not being said, hand over decisions with real authority, hold people to their own commitments, and develop someone who can eventually replace them. These skills are learned fastest when the owner models them in weekly coaching conversations.

How can a small business owner improve manager engagement?

Give managers real authority over routine decisions, replace status meetings with weekly coaching conversations, and make every manager responsible for developing at least one person. Gallup found managers who received coaching-focused development had up to 22% higher engagement and teams with up to 18% higher engagement.

What does the Bible say about delegation in leadership?

In Exodus 18, Jethro warns Moses that carrying every decision alone will wear out both him and the people, and tells him to appoint trustworthy leaders to handle smaller matters. In 2 Timothy 2:2, Paul tells Timothy to entrust what he has learned to faithful people who will teach others, a pattern of multiplying leaders rather than hoarding work.

About the Author

Karl Diffenderfer is a Certified Master Business Coach and the founder and CEO of Higher Impact, a business coaching and leadership development firm in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. Over more than 15 years, he has logged more than 10,000 documented coaching sessions with faith-driven, family-owned, and trades businesses. He built and sold a business before devoting his work to developing owners and the leaders who serve with them.

Sources

Ready for your next step?

Start with a complimentary conversation with Karl. You will leave with a clear next step.

Talk With Karl
Higher Impact - Business & Leadership Coaching
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.